The Unexpected Silver Lining of Trade Tensions

In a surprising twist of economic fate, the recent tariff threats from U.S. President Donald Trump toward Canada could actually help lower your monthly mortgage payments. As the Bank of Canada prepares for its interest rate announcement tomorrow, many experts anticipate the seventh consecutive rate cut, potentially dropping the benchmark rate to 2.75% – a move that could directly benefit Canadian homeowners and borrowers.

But how exactly do international trade tensions translate to savings in your pocket? Let’s break down this complex economic relationship and what it means for your finances in the coming months.

Understanding the Current Interest Rate Environment

The Bank of Canada’s overnight interest rate currently sits at 3%, having gradually decreased from its peak of 5% in June 2024. This downward trend represents a significant shift from the rapid rate increases that followed the COVID-19 pandemic.

Recent Interest Rate History

The pattern of steady rate decreases reflects the Bank of Canada’s response to changing economic conditions, primarily the gradual reduction of inflation toward its target of approximately 2%.

The Trump Tariff Factor

President Trump has threatened significant tariffs on Canadian goods and services entering the United States. While these threats create economic uncertainty, they’ve introduced a new variable into the interest rate equation that could benefit borrowers.

According to Desjardins Group deputy chief economist Randall Bartlett, “It’s a very difficult position for the Bank of Canada to be in.” The central bank must now balance multiple competing factors:

• Falling inflation (which supports lower rates)
• Economic growth concerns (which support lower rates)
• Potential tariff-induced inflation (which would typically suggest higher rates)
• Risk of job losses in affected sectors (which support lower rates)

This complex situation creates a paradox where economic threats actually accelerate interest rate cuts.

Why More Rate Cuts Are Likely

Concordia University economist Moshe Lander explains the Bank of Canada’s likely reasoning: “If the cut does materialize, it’s because the Bank of Canada is worried about an economic slowdown related to the tariffs and all the uncertainty around it.”

The central bank aims to use rate cuts strategically to:

1. Discourage saving and encourage spending: Lower rates make saving less attractive while making borrowing more affordable
2. Stimulate business investment: Companies face lower costs for capital expenditures
3. Support government stimulus: Lower borrowing costs enable larger deficit spending if needed
4. Weaken the Canadian dollar: A weaker dollar makes exports more competitive

CIBC expects the Bank of Canada to deliver a quarter-point cut on Wednesday, with more cuts to follow if trade uncertainty persists. As Andrew Grantham, senior economist with CIBC Capital Markets, notes, the central bank “can’t solve the tariff issue” with rate cuts, but it can “help the economy transition through the turbulence.”

What This Means for Your Mortgage

The impact on your mortgage depends on what type you have:

Variable-Rate Mortgages

If you hold a variable-rate mortgage, you could see immediate benefits. A 0.25% rate cut typically translates directly to your mortgage rate, potentially reducing your monthly payments as early as Thursday morning.

For example, on a $500,000 mortgage with a 25-year amortization:

• At 4.00%: Monthly payment of approximately $2,630
• At 3.75%: Monthly payment of approximately $2,560
• Monthly savings: $70 (or $840 annually)

Fixed-Rate Mortgages

For those with fixed-rate mortgages, the relationship is more complex. Fixed mortgage rates are influenced by bond market movements rather than directly by the Bank of Canada rate.

However, economic uncertainty is already affecting bond returns. CIBC recently offered a five-year fixed rate below 4%, suggesting that fixed rates may also trend downward if economic conditions remain uncertain.

The Mortgage Rate Disconnect

One puzzling aspect of the current market is that fixed mortgage rates haven’t dropped as significantly as the overnight rate. Since June 2024, the overnight rate has fallen by 2%, yet five-year fixed mortgage rates haven’t followed the same trajectory.

This disconnect occurs because:

• Fixed mortgage rates are tied to bond yields, not the overnight rate
• Canadian bonds have remained relatively strong despite rate cuts
• Economic uncertainty affects bonds differently than central bank rates

B.C. real estate analyst Steve Saretsky points out that bond yields could weaken further, potentially driving fixed rates down even more.

The Short-Term vs. Long-Term Outlook

While lower interest rates may provide immediate financial relief for borrowers, the long-term economic impact of actual tariffs could be severe.

Desjardins expects Canada would fall into a recession by mid-year if steep tariffs remain in place. This economic contraction would likely trigger even more aggressive rate cuts, potentially pushing the overnight rate below 2% by year-end.

Is This the Right Move?

Not all economists agree on the timing of these rate cuts. Moshe Lander suggests a more cautious approach: “If it were me, I would hold off on a cut. The tariffs haven’t really come in yet… If you start using up the arrows in your quiver now, what’s that going to leave you when or if tariffs actually do come into play?”

This perspective highlights a key concern: the Bank of Canada may be reacting too quickly to threats rather than actual economic impacts.

Beyond Tariffs: Other Factors Affecting Investment

While Trump’s tariff threats create uncertainty, local policies also play a significant role in economic confidence. In Quebec, Premier François Legault has pointed to tariff threats as a deterrent to business investment.

However, as Lander notes, “The problems facing Quebec are so much more than tariffs, and it’s mostly his government’s policies making Quebec an unattractive place.” These include:

• Tougher language laws
• Immigration policies
• High provincial tax rates
• General policy uncertainty

These factors underscore that interest rates, while important, are just one element in a complex economic picture.

What Should Borrowers Do?

With interest rates likely to continue falling in the near term, borrowers face important decisions:

For Variable-Rate Holders

• Enjoy the immediate benefits of rate cuts
• Consider maintaining your current payment amount to pay down principal faster
• Prepare for potential economic volatility by building emergency savings

For Fixed-Rate Holders

• Monitor markets for refinancing opportunities if rates fall significantly
• Calculate the cost-benefit of breaking your current mortgage against potential savings
• Consider converting to variable if your risk tolerance allows and you believe rates will continue to fall

For New Borrowers

• Compare both variable and fixed options carefully
• Consider shorter fixed terms to maintain flexibility
• Ensure you qualify at higher stress-test rates to protect against future increases

The Global Context

Canada’s situation isn’t happening in isolation. Central banks worldwide are navigating similarly complex environments, balancing inflation concerns against growth worries while managing political and trade uncertainties.

The Bank of Canada’s decisions will be closely watched by other central banks as a potential indicator of how monetary policy can respond to trade threats and economic uncertainty.

Looking Ahead

As the Bank of Canada makes its announcement tomorrow, the implications extend far beyond a simple number. The decision will signal how the central bank views the balance of risks in the economy and provide insights into its strategy for navigating this uncertain environment.

For the average Canadian homeowner or borrower, this complex economic dance may ultimately deliver a welcome gift: lower borrowing costs during an otherwise uncertain time. The question remains whether these short-term benefits will outweigh the potential longer-term economic challenges that tariffs could bring.

Regardless of tomorrow’s specific decision, one thing is clear: the relationship between international trade, interest rates, and your mortgage has never been more direct. Understanding this connection may help you make better financial decisions in the months ahead as this economic story continues to unfold.

Previous Page