When you’re trying to guess which way the Bank of Canada (BoC) will move on interest rates, there’s no shortage of factors to consider. One day, it’s all about weak job numbers. The next day, it’s about a surge in consumer spending or inflation creeping higher. Most recently, new inflation data for January has sent ripples across the financial community. Up until this release, many were betting that the Bank of Canada might slash interest rates again in March. But now, those odds have dropped to under 30%, leaving economists, homeowners, and prospective homebuyers scrambling to figure out what’s next.

In this in-depth article, we’ll dive into the heart of the issue and examine the shifting rate-cut probabilities. We’ll unpack the details of January’s inflation numbers, reveal why some experts still expect more rate cuts, and discuss the implications for mortgages, real estate, and the broader Canadian economy. Strap in—it’s a lot to take in, but by the end, you’ll have a clearer understanding of the forces tugging at Canada’s monetary policy.

The Current Economic Landscape

Canada’s economy is frequently caught between global forces—particularly those emanating from the United States—and domestic priorities like housing affordability and job growth. Over the past few years, we’ve seen the Bank of Canada respond to shifting trade policies, new tariff concerns, and fluctuating energy prices.

But it’s not all doom and gloom. Despite these headwinds, consumer sentiment often remains relatively robust. Canada’s labor market had a notable streak of job gains, and even though wage growth can lag behind rising living costs, the fundamentals do not always point toward a strong need for rate cuts.

When setting rates, the Bank of Canada looks at a number of different gauges, such as:

• Headline Inflation Rate
• Core Inflation Measures (CPI-Trim, CPI-Median, CPI excluding food and energy)
• GDP Growth
• Employment Data
• Housing Market Stability

Even if some metrics suggest a slowing economy, others might signal strength. This tug of war often leaves the Bank of Canada in a bind. In recent months, the big question looming over everyone’s mind has been: Will they lower rates further to stimulate the economy, or hold steady given signs of resilient inflation and employment?

January Inflation Data: A Closer Look

January’s inflation report dropped a few key takeaways that have changed the conversation about rate cuts. Let’s break down the numbers:

1. Headline Inflation Rate
   • Climbed to 1.9% year-over-year, a slight bump from December’s 1.8%.
   • This aligns with market expectations, so it wasn’t a shock to the system.
2. Energy Prices
   • The rise in headline CPI was partly driven by higher energy costs, especially gasoline (+8.6%) and natural gas (+4.8%).
   • Energy prices often see wild swings, so while they can move inflation figures, policymakers tend to look through short-term spikes unless they persist.
3. GST Holiday Relief
   • From mid-December to mid-February, a temporary GST holiday helped reduce prices on several items.
   • Food purchased at restaurants declined (-5.1% y/y), alcoholic beverages fell (-3.6% y/y), and toys/games/hobby supplies dropped (-6.8% y/y).
   • These are temporary reprieves, which means inflation in these categories could bounce back once the holiday ends.
4. Core Inflation Measures
   • CPI excluding food and energy stayed at 2.2% y/y, indicating that underlying inflation (sans the most volatile components) remained relatively stable.
   • The seasonally adjusted annualized rate of CPI excluding food and energy slowed to 1.6% in January, a big drop from 4.0% in December.
   • CPI-Trim and CPI-Median—the BoC’s preferred core measures—edged higher to 2.7% y/y, suggesting that inflationary pressure hasn’t vanished.
5. Three-Month Annualized Trend
   • Has been floating above 3%, which is notably above the Bank of Canada’s 2% target.
   • This supports the narrative that core inflation “should continue to grind higher,” according to TD economist James Orlando.

When you put it all together, the inflation picture is mixed. Sure, energy prices are pushing up the headline figure, and some core measures are looking hotter. But seasonal adjustments and one-off events like the GST holiday are also pulling down other categories. For policymakers, that means there isn’t a simple consensus that inflation is either too hot or too cold.

Bank of Canada Rate Cut Odds: What Changed?

Prior to this inflation report, we had a good chunk of the market pricing in a significant probability of a 25-basis-point rate cut at the March 12 policy meeting. However, after these new numbers rolled out, the market odds plunged to under 30%.

Why such a big change? One reason is that many see the BoC as having less room to cut rates when inflation is running near (or even above) target. Cutting rates typically aims to stimulate economic activity, but it can also fuel more inflation. If inflation is already at or near the upper band of what the BoC tolerates, it’s riskier to keep lowering rates.

Derek Holt from Scotiabank sums it up neatly:

“There is too much underlying inflationary pressure in Canada to warrant an inflation-targeting central bank easing monetary policy further.”

If inflation is “too warm,” as Holt suggests, the central bank might worry about overstimulating the economy, pushing prices up further, and overcooking inflation expectations.

Divergent Economists: A Battle of Views

But wait, not everyone agrees. Some economists see the broad picture differently, urging caution in interpreting the latest inflation data. Notable among them are experts from Oxford Economics, who argue that while inflation might look strong in some areas, the economy is still facing substantial risks—especially from trade uncertainties and the potential slowdown in global growth.

Here’s what Tony Stillo from Oxford Economics has to say:

“We believe the BoC will look through the temporary price shock and instead focus on the negative implications for the Canadian economy and heightened trade policy uncertainty, leaving it on track to lower the policy rate another 75bps to 2.25% by June 2025.”

He’s pointing out that even though inflation is running hot in some corners, the Bank of Canada might not see it as sustainable inflation. If they interpret it as a blip—driven by temporary energy or tax factors—they might continue their rate-cutting trajectory in an effort to buffer against external economic threats like global trade wars or weaker U.S. demand.

This divergence highlights a classic challenge in monetary policy: Do you place more weight on present inflation readings, or do you project forward and take preventive action against what might lie ahead?

The Role of Employment Figures

Inflation is not the only piece of the puzzle. A big part of the rate-setting equation is the health of the labor market. In January, Canada posted higher-than-expected job growth numbers. While one month doesn’t dictate a trend, strong employment figures make it tougher for the BoC to justify cutting rates.

• A robust job market typically boosts consumer spending and confidence.
• Higher employment can lead to wage growth, which in turn fuels inflation.

Derek Holt touched on this point when he said,

“The state of the job market also does not merit further easing. Canadian inflation remains too warm for the Bank of Canada to continue easing.”

If the data is showing the economy isn’t floundering, a rate cut might be seen as unnecessary or even dangerous. However, critics argue that if the global outlook worsens or trade barriers intensify, today’s job strength could evaporate quickly. That leads us to the real question: Is the BoC better off preparing for a storm or reacting once it arrives?

Impact on Mortgages and the Housing Market

For Canadians, especially those shopping for a new home or renewing a mortgage, these rate speculations can feel like a roller coaster. While the Bank of Canada’s policy rate directly influences prime rates—affecting variable-rate mortgages—it also indirectly influences fixed mortgage rates.

Here’s a quick rundown of how rate decisions ripple through the mortgage world:

1. Variable-Rate Mortgages
   • Typically tied to the prime rate, which often moves closely with the Bank of Canada’s overnight rate.
   • If the BoC cuts rates, variable mortgage holders usually see lower monthly payments. Conversely, no cuts could mean stable or slightly higher variable rates if banks adjust their spreads.
2. Fixed-Rate Mortgages
   • More closely related to bond yields. However, bond yields often reflect market expectations of future economic and monetary policy moves.
   • When the odds of a rate cut drop, bond yields may rise, nudging fixed mortgage rates higher.
3. Housing Affordability
   • If rates remain steady or climb, some prospective buyers may feel squeezed.
   • On the other hand, stable rates can also indicate economic resilience, which generally supports the real estate market.

While a single data release doesn’t usually spark radical mortgage rate changes overnight, sentiment matters. If the market collectively shifts its perception of future rate cuts, lenders might re-evaluate their offerings sooner rather than later.

Real Estate Outlook: Balancing Acts

Real estate in Canada—particularly in key markets like Toronto, Vancouver, Montreal, and Ottawa—remains a hot topic. Even small shifts in mortgage rates can significantly impact affordability, especially for first-time buyers.

1. Buyer Psychology
   • Expectations of lower rates can spark a rush to lock in mortgages, leading to a mini buying frenzy.
   • If buyers suspect rates will stay the same (or go up), some may hold off to see if prices cool.
2. Inventory and Listings
   • Recent data suggested listings surged in January, partly because homeowners were spooked by tariff uncertainties and the possibility of a slower spring market.
   • More listings usually ease price pressures, but if rates remain attractive, increased buyer demand can offset that effect.
3. Regional Variances
   • Western Canada might be more exposed to energy price movements.
   • Eastern provinces could feel different impacts from manufacturing slowdowns or trade shifts with Europe.

For real estate professionals—brokers, agents, lenders—understanding these nuances is crucial. The interplay between rate expectations, consumer confidence, and available housing stock can shape market dynamics for months.

GST Holiday Effects and Other Temporary Measures

One of the more interesting wrinkles in the inflation data is the GST holiday that ran from mid-December to mid-February. This measure effectively lowered prices on a handful of consumer categories, from restaurant meals to alcoholic beverages to toys and hobby supplies.

• Why It Matters for Inflation: When the holiday ends, prices in those categories may bounce back, giving a temporary inflation boost.
• Why It Matters for Consumers: Some consumers might have accelerated purchases or enjoyed a bit of extra disposable income, which can artificially inflate economic performance for the period.

This scenario is a reminder that not all inflation or deflation is structural. Some is purely policy-driven and short-lived. For the Bank of Canada, discerning “real” inflation from “transient” inflation is critical for setting rates.

A Snapshot of Expert Forecasts (Table)

Below is a simplified table summarizing various economists’ positions on the upcoming rate moves:

As you can see, opinions run the gamut. Some expect multiple cuts, while others say we’re at—or near—the end of an easing cycle.

Balancing Risks: Trade Uncertainty vs. Inflation Pressures

The Bank of Canada doesn’t operate in a vacuum. Whenever they consider a policy move, they have to account for external forces like:

• Global trade tensions
• U.S. fiscal and monetary policies
• Commodity price volatility

At any moment, a fresh wave of tariffs or a sudden surge in global economic growth could upend the calculations. Tony Stillo from Oxford Economics explicitly mentions the possibility that the BoC might “look through” short-term inflation spikes if it believes global risks threaten Canada’s medium- to long-term growth.

Still, as James Orlando points out, there’s a real risk in over-correcting. If you keep cutting rates while inflation is above target, you might lose your grip on price stability. It’s a delicate balancing act, and the next few weeks leading up to the March 12 decision will be telling.

Chart: Core Inflation Trends

While we can’t embed a real graphical chart here, let’s create a simple text-based representation of how core inflation measures (CPI-Trim and CPI-Median) have trended year-over-year for the last few months:

Month       CPI-Trim      CPI-Median
-------------------------------------
Nov 2024      2.4%          2.5%
Dec 2024      2.5%          2.6%
Jan 2025      2.7%          2.7%

Observations:

• Both CPI-Trim and CPI-Median show an upward climb from November to January.
• This suggests that the underlying trend in prices is increasing, reinforcing concerns about persistent inflationary pressure.

Looking Ahead: Potential Scenarios

What are the possible outcomes for Canada’s monetary policy in the coming months? Let’s explore three scenarios:

1. Scenario A: Rate Cut in March
   • Likelihood: Low (under 30% by current market odds).
   • Rationale: The BoC would need to see evidence of a sudden economic deterioration—perhaps triggered by fresh trade barriers or a spike in unemployment.
   • Implications: Variable mortgage rates would likely dip, offering relief to mortgage holders and potentially stimulating the housing market in the short term.
2. Scenario B: No March Cut, but Later Cuts in 2025
   • Likelihood: Moderate.
   • Rationale: The Bank could adopt a “wait-and-see” approach, gathering more data on inflation and economic growth. If the global outlook dims in Q2 or Q3, they may decide that additional cuts are warranted.
   • Implications: A pause now won’t dramatically move mortgage rates, but persistent economic struggles later in the year could lead to more rate-cut talk, keeping homeowners and buyers on their toes.
3. Scenario C: Extended Pause and Potential Hikes
   • Likelihood: Also possible but perhaps overshadowed by economic uncertainties.
   • Rationale: If inflation continues to climb well above the target and the job market remains robust, the BoC might decide it needs to tighten policy—or at least hold off on cuts for the foreseeable future.
   • Implications: Mortgage holders with variable rates wouldn’t see relief, and fixed rates might trend upward if bond yields surge. Real estate markets could cool if borrowing costs rise too much.

Final Thoughts

Balancing inflation and employment concerns is never simple, and the Bank of Canada’s decision-making process is further complicated by the political and economic winds blowing around the world. From the vantage point of early 2025, it’s clear that inflation numbers—especially core measures—are running hotter than some might like. That’s one reason why market odds for a March cut have tumbled below 30%.

However, skeptics warn that fixating on current inflation could miss the forest for the trees. There’s a chance that global pressures will weigh heavily on Canada’s economy, eventually justifying more cuts. Economists remain split, and the only consensus is that things can change quickly. A surprise in the labor market, a tweet announcing new tariffs, or a sudden jump in commodity prices can swing sentiment in a matter of days.

For mortgage seekers, the see-saw of rate expectations underscores the importance of staying nimble. If you’re on the hunt for a home, you might consider locking in a rate if you sense a no-cut scenario on the horizon. If, however, you believe the Bank will eventually cave to economic pressures, you might opt for a variable rate in hopes of benefitting from future cuts. Of course, that strategy carries its own risks—especially if inflation data continues to climb and the BoC decides it must tap the brakes.

One thing’s for sure: in a world as interconnected as ours, monetary policy in Canada can’t be looked at in isolation. From trade uncertainties to energy prices, from the U.S. Federal Reserve’s moves to domestic employment trends, each piece of data can tip the scales. And if the first few weeks of 2025 are any indication, we’re in for plenty of twists and turns in the months ahead.

With the next Bank of Canada rate announcement set for March 12, all eyes are on Governor Tiff Macklem and his team. Will they hold the line, focusing on inflation numbers, or will global storm clouds force them to cut rates again? Economists like Derek Holt bet on “no cut” due to strong underlying inflation, while Oxford Economics stands firm on “more cuts” ahead. Until we get a definitive statement, it’s a waiting game—one filled with reams of data, shifting economic crosswinds, and more than a little speculation.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Always consult with a qualified financial advisor or mortgage professional for personalized guidance.

Previous Page